Does anyone play the melodica for reasons other than the sound?

Homepage Forums General melodica discussion Does anyone play the melodica for reasons other than the sound?

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
  • Author
  • #11019

    Does anyone play the melodica for reasons other than the sound?
    I for one am not a great fan of the free reed sound. In particular the accordion or concertina. I don’t care for the melodica models that sound accordion like or some of the two-handed techniques that sound accordion-ish.

    Why do I play the melodica then?

    I’m old enough to remember when the small portable electronic keyboards were not around. It was handy to have a small keyboard that didn’t require batteries or be a piece of furniture.
    Also the expression!!! the ability to combine those breath-flow techniques combined with keyboard precision is wonderful!
    Just curious about the rest of you and your attraction to the instrument?

    AvatarDavid Colpitts

    I am new to the instrument, and am interested mainly because it offers the free-reed sound with the full chromaticity of the piano keyboard. All my other instruments are diatonic, and this will open other keys to me. However, I am obsessed with the Janko conversions I have done; I will try to find a way to send sound links for all to hear, once I have another month or so under my belt.


    Daren BanarsëDaren Banarsë

    I was drawn to the melodica for a few reasons. I trained as a classical pianist before working as a composer, and dreamed of playing a wind instrument, where you could swell notes and play with expression. I also wanted to play an instrument I could travel with, put in my pocket and take anywhere.

    I tried several instruments for around a year each. My first was a wooden recorder, then a chromatic harmonica, then an accordina. I loved the accordina, but it just wasn’t loud enough. After that I tried the melodica, which I’ve stuck with ever since. Of course the advantage is that I already play the piano, though as melodica/piano players know, although the key layout is the same, the technique is entirely different.

    I’ve always loved the sound of the concertina, so I’m quite happy to be able to achieve a very similar sound.


    More than the sound I’d be very interested to see the construction of your Janko conversion. I’ve considered that myself in the past.


    Melodicas Hohner Soprano and Alto are narrow enough to be played left-handed, and they actually play where your attention is.

    • This reply was modified 2 months, 2 weeks ago by AvatarMysha.
    AvatarAlan Brinton

    The sound is a big factor, but another is that it encourages improvisation.

    AvatarPál Krammer

    (for some reason my reply to this topic disappeared after making a very minor edit – I’m attempting to re-post it; my apologies if this somehow results in multiple identical replies)

    David: a question for you below.

    Initially I became interested in harmonicas and bought a few different models in different keys. I became a little disappointed in harmonica forums, books, and YouTube videos, because 99% of harmonica discussion seems to involve bending notes (certainly for Blues); it seems few are interested in playing the harmonica straight in First Position.

    Then, on a sax forum, someone who was actually interested in accordions bought a melodica because it was far less expensive and then a discussion ensued about both accordions and melodicas. Initially I’d never considered the accordion seriously, but as I learned about it, the register switches, the reed banks, the bass buttons, I became fascinated. I also like the artistic work of the faceplate and register switches of accordions. My local music store had five last month; they’ve sold two. I’ve given myself a year to study them before I consider buying one.

    Anyway, that melodica discussion along with samples of play led me to investigate further – which led me to videos and reviews on this site. I bought my first melodica, a P-32D, just last week.

    So – the Jankó keyboard! Pál von Jankó was a Hungarian, a pianist, and an engineer; I am just a Hungarian and an engineer. However, I am familiar with the clever design of his keyboard, although I’ve never seen a real one. In his day, such a keyboard would be mechanically complex; today, with electronics, such a keyboard is very feasible! So, David, have you constructed one? If so, surely it isn’t for a melodica – but perhaps I’m wrong?

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.