Home / Forums / General melodica discussion / I spot a melodica! / Reply To: I spot a melodica! Reply To: I spot a melodica! June 16, 2017 at 1:51 pm #9011 Alan BrintonParticipant I think what tipped me in favor of B was discordance that is often characteristic — in tuning a piano, for example — of something that is done mechanically without the assistance of the human ear or eye. But I was wrong. I don’t listen to much Celtic music, but to me C does sound like it could be an imitation of what’s done in A. So I also considered C.