Home / Forums / Vintage Melodicas / Vintage Hohner "Student" versus vintage Hohner "Alto" / Reply To: Vintage Hohner "Student" versus vintage Hohner "Alto" Reply To: Vintage Hohner "Student" versus vintage Hohner "Alto" August 20, 2014 at 10:24 pm #3010 Rick ReidParticipant I think the main difference is that the student model has fewer buttons for smaller hands. I have both the alto and the soprano models. They sound of the the two instruments is identical except for the difference in pitch ranges.